Facebook Embed Plug Script

For Int'l Holocaust Remembrance Week - the 75th anniversary of liberation of Auschwitz

"Netanyahu: Allies could have saved 4 million Jews if they’d bombed death camps in 1942" The Times of Israel, 4/24/17
 
Israeli P.M. Benjamin Netanyahu condemned int'l complacency
to earlier intel of Nazi's mass murdering of Jewish people 
at Yad Vashem Holocaust Remembrance ceremony 
"In bitter Holocaust Remembrance Day speech citing new UN documents, Israel's PM castigates global indifference 75 years ago, says it persists today.

Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday launched a blistering assault on Allied policy during World War II, saying world powers’ failure to bomb the Nazi concentration camps from 1942 cost the lives of four million Jews and millions of others.

Citing recently released UN documents
that show the Allies were aware of the scale of the Holocaust in 1942, some two years earlier than previously assumed, Netanyahu said in a speech marking Holocaust Remembrance Day that this new research assumed “a terrible significance.”
Film stills from "What the Allies Knew" by Virginie Linhart,
produced by Fabienne Servan-Schreiber and Cinétévé

“If the powers in 1942 had acted against the death camps — and all that was needed was repeated bombing of the camps — had they acted then, they could have saved 4 million Jews and millions of other people,” he said at the official state ceremony marking the start of the memorial day.
Allies declined bombinb railways leading to genocide camps 

“The powers knew, and they did not act,” he told the audience at the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial in Jerusalem. “When terrible crimes were being committed against the Jews, when our brothers and sisters were being sent to the furnaces,” he went on, “the powers knew and did not act.”

In a bleak and bitter address, the Israeli prime minister said that the Holocaust was enabled by three factors: the vast hatred of the Jews, global indifference to the horrors, and “the terrible weakness of our people in the Diaspora.”
Iran's "World without Zionism" (photo: BlazingCatFur)
Anti-Semitism had not disappeared, and “it would be naive to think” that it would do so in the foreseeable future, he said. It was being exacerbated by “hatred from the East,” led by Iran and the Islamic State, he added.

"Bombing Auschwitz" 75th Anniversary Preview: The Great Moral Dilemma of the 20th Century
In May 1944, Rabbi Michael Weissmandl sent the Auschwitz Protocol, along with a plea for help and a demand for Allied air forces to bomb Auschwitz, to Roswell McClelland at the War Refugee Board in Switzerland.

Should the Allies have risked killing Auschwitz prisoners and bombed the camp to stop future atrocities? Join historians, survivors and experts as they consider one of the great moral dilemmas of the 20th century.
 
Watch Secrets of the Dead on PBS SoCal Tue, Jan 21 @ 9:00 PM, Wed, Jan 22 @ 2:00 AM, Thu, Jan 30 @ 11:00 PM. Check your local PBS listings.

D-Day to V-E Day: World War II continued for almost 11 months after the successful Normandy landings in France on June 6, 1944, commonly known as D-Day.
American troops liberating Dachau Concentration Camp

At "The Liberators" documentary screening by the Zachor Foundation, Holocaust survivors, Ben Lesser and Joshua Kaufman discuss their reunions with the Yankee soldiers who liberated them from Dachau Concentration Camp.

   

Roumanian Holocaust survivor, Amram Deutsch, recounts his experiences in Nazi camps.

 

Czech Republic's Consul General Pavel Sepelak and Prof. Abraham Sion of Ariel University in Samaria discuss the Allies' mistake of sacrificing Czechoslovakia to delay war with Nazi Germany.

Watch acclaimed, "Son of Saul," drama here (since TV programmers omit the Oscar-winner this Holocaust Remembrance Week)


Auschwitz Nazi commands Son of Saul's Géza Röhrig
(Updated 1/23/20) Golden Globe and Academy Award winner, Son of Saul, depicts Hungarian-Jewish volunteers  participating in the National Socialists' genocide of Jewish Europeans at Auschwitz concentration camp. It may be the most realistic depiction of the worst genocide in the civilized world. Why, during the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, aren't staffs at TV channels showing it?

October 1944, Auschwitz-Birkenau. Saul Ausländer (portrayed by Géza Röhrig) is a Hungarian member of the Sonderkommando, the group of Jewish prisoners removed from prison duty for electing to assist the Nazis in the machinery of large-scale extermination. While working, Saul discovers the body of a boy he takes for his son.



Mr. Rohrig's portrayal of the leading role in 2015 Holocaust drama "Son of Saul" helped earn the graphic Hungarian, Holocaust re-creation Best Foreign Language Film recognition from both Hollywood's Golden Globes and the Academy Awards in 2016.



Review of "Son of Saul-  A stunning, excoriating Holocaust drama" Peter Bradshaw in The Guardian 28 April '16:

Laslo Nemes on JooTube.TV
The experience of evil and the experience of being in hell are what are offered by this devastating and terrifying film by László Nemes, set in the Auschwitz II-Birkenau death camp in 1944.
Saul, played by the 48-year-old Hungarian actor Géza Röhrig, is a Jewish prisoner who has been made part of the Sonderkommando, inmates given tiny, temporary privileges in return for policing their own extermination. They must manage the day-to-day business of herding bewildered prisoners out of the trains and up to the very doors of the gas chambers and then removing the bodies, the chief task being to pacify the victims in advance with their simple presence, silently shoring up the Nazi soldiers’ reassuring lies about these being simply showers. They are bit-part players in a theatre of horror.

More than 40 dignitaries gathered in Jerusalem today to attend the World Holocaust Forum during International Holocaust Remembrance Week which culminates on Monday 27 January - commemorating the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz.
 

All US TV network affiliates in Los Angeles found it fit to pre-empt regular programming to air hours of the Senate's hearing to impeach the pro-Jewish President Donald Trump. The prosecution is being spearheaded by liberal Jewish Congressmen Adam Schiff and Jerome Nadler, supported by Sen. Chuck Schumer.

Despite Son of Saul's lauded, educational depiction of the conditions under European, National Socialist (Nazi) rule, just 4-years after winning the Oscar, no TV programmer in the US is telecasting Son of Saul. Why not?

  
For an International Holocaust Remembrance Day program in 2017, L.A. Museum of the Holocaust's Paul Nussbaum, and fellow, Hungarian-Jewish American immigrant, Steven Geiger, (founder of the Mensch Foundation) presented the film's screening, accompanied by a talk with Hungarian-Jewish actor Geza Rohrig, who portrayed "Son of Saul" Auslander.


Academy Award winning actor, Geza Rohrig ("Son of Saul") answered audience questions at L.A. Museum of the Holocaust's screening of Son of Saul on the weekend of Int'l Holocaust Remembrance Day in Los Angeles. Moderated by Paul S. Nussbaum, L.A. MotH's President.


Following the discussion with Son of Saul's Geza Rohrig and L.A. Museum of Holocaust's Paul Nussbaum, Mensch Foundation founder, Steven Geiger, introduces Tamas Szeles, Hungarian Consul General in Los Angeles.


"Son of Saul" spurs Mensch Foundation's Steven Geiger to offer an exposition of the history of Jewry and anti-Semitism in Hungary. 

Watch Son of Saul for $4 via YouTube pay-per-rental:


If you'd like to watch it on your big-screen O.T.T., though it is not on Netflix, it is on Amazon Prime Video here.

How director Laszlo Nemes' Hungarian-Jewish identity contributed to Son of Saul's winning Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film

The Oscar-winning filmmaker, Laszlo Nemes, reveals to JooTube his own Jewish identity- and responds to the dilemma of Jewish-centric questions in producing the film.

Following a Hollywood screening, Mensch Foundation director, Steven Geiger, an immigrant from Communist Hungary, discusses anti-Semitism then and now.

 


Hungarian anti-Semitism expert and author, Mrs. Susanne Reyto, reacts to the movie. Mrs. Reyto explains how Arab countries adopted their Nazi-allies' political antisemitism to unify pan-Arab populations against. Under the guidance of Jerusalem Mufti Haj Amin al-Husseini and Egypt's President Nasser, they Islamized Germany's propaganda experts to politicize existing Muslim Jew-hatred - to oppose the legal sanctuary for Jews in Palestine. 

They continued the expulsion of Jewish citizens from Arab countries, which started in Iraq in 1941. By Israel's statehood in 1948, Muslims had expelled approximately 900,000 Jewish citizens and appropriated their homes, property, possessions, savings, and businesses - in the Nazi-style.

Watch Museum of Tolerance rabbis call on the President to federalize (and for black leaders to condemn) anti-Jewish, bias attacks

Mr. Josef Gluck, saved the license plate number of the attempted massacrist, Grafton Thomas, who was influenced by Black Liberation extremism, as were the attackers of yeshiva-adjacent grocery in Jersey City, according to a neighbor

Rabbi Marvin Hier calls on Pres Trump
to involve Feds in hate-crime policing

Los Angeles, December 30 -  Rabbi Marvin Hier, founder and dean of the Simon Wiesenthal Center will be urging President Trump to instruct the FBI to create a special task force in wake of unending attacks against Jews and their religious institutions. The latest attack was a violent machete slashing attack against Jewish worshipers in Monsey, New York at a Hankuah party on Saturday night.

The New York Post Editorial Board's Op/Ed today names causes for NYC's 8, minority-inflicted assaults on Jewish people in NYC Metro area:"

"The mayor (DeBlasio) skirts over the true culprits, such as: The city’s (and state’s) failure to address serious mental illness. A lawyer for alleged Monsey stabber Grafton Thomas says he has “a long history” of hospitalizations.

New York’s growing softness on crime. As The Post reported Saturday, the state’s new no-bail law will mean a quick get-out-of-jail-free card for all but one of the accused attackers in the eight anti-Jewish crimes in the city last week. Tiffany Harris is the rule, not the exception.

“You have to beat the hell out of somebody — or murder them — for there to be any consequences,” laments Dov Hikind of Americans Against Anti-Semitism.

Jew-hatred among some blacks, which de Blasio, Gov. Cuomo and other Democrats refuse to call out by name. Some black leaders even promote anti-Semitism...
The attacks on Jews in New York during Hanukah and the vandalism in Los Angeles of Nessah Synagogue and numerous spurred automobiles inspired Simon Wiesenthal Center dean Rabbi Marvin Hier to call for the FBI to confront anti-Semites in greater priority. 

Rabbi Marvin Hier, dean of the Simon Wiesenthal Center,  urges Pres. Trump assign federal intervention to avert violence against Jewish people, places, and possessions.


 

Rabbi Hier responded to reporters' questions, including JooTube's inquiring about the Black establishment legitimizing Nation of Islam's Louis Farrakhan's dogma, and the Democratic Party leadership embracing of Muslim anti-Zionists, Reps. Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib.

L.A.'s Nessah synagogue accused-ransacker, Russian-Pennsylvanian Anton Redding, may have been among the tens of thousands who watched Furry Potato's revealing of synagogues' security vulnerabilities and taunting guards on YouTube




Wiesenthal Center's Executive Director, Rabbi Meyer May, calls on the Chairperson of the Congressional Black Caucus, Rep. Karen Bass, who is the Museum of Tolerance district House Representative, as well as faith leaders and anti-racism activists among minority communities, to issue public denouncements of racist violence and crimes against Jewish people from all of their peoples-of-color.


In view of the spate of antisemitic attacks on orthodox Jews by people-of-color, Wiesenthal Center's Executive Director, Rabbi Meyer H. May calls upon Rep. Karen Bass and black faith-leaders to take a public stand denouncing hate towards Jewish people.

Express your appreciation for JooTube's year-round publishing. Donate through the link in the right column. Happy Hankuah and New Year!

Why British Jews are worried by Jeremy Corbyn - and what does election portend for Americans?

What will neo-Left antisemitism portend for Jewish-Americans (and Christian Zionists) in 2020?

Why British Jews Are Worried by Jeremy Corbyn

Has denying the reality of anti-Semitism become a left-wing loyalty test? By Helen Lewis in The Atlantic December 11, '19
Jeremy Corbyn and Boris Johnson debate
It is an astonishing statistic: Some 87 percent of British Jews believe that Jeremy Corbyn—one of two men who could be prime minister in a few days’ time—is anti-Semitic. How did we get here? Corbyn’s party, Labour, has strong connections with the Jewish community, dating back to its earliest days. Yet a deep distrust has developed between the two since he became Labour leader in 2015, and the issue has dogged Corbyn throughout this election campaign. . . .
At the same time, the other plausible candidate to be the next prime minister—the Conservative leader, Boris Johnson—has faced his own questions over his use of racial epithets and his attitudes toward minorities. Racism directed at faith communities in Britain has therefore become a deeply partisan left/right issue: Any mention of “Labour anti-Semitism” is met with cries of “Tory Islamophobia.” ... 
Yet the question of anti-Semitism is also divisive within the left. Jewish voters I spoke with over the past several weeks told me of feeling as though the entire community had been “gaslit”—that the reality of anti-Semitism was being minimized by the party leadership—and that denying this reality had become a way to demonstrate loyalty to Corbyn and his radical anti-austerity agenda. This feeling is aggravated by persistent suggestions from the hard left that anti-Semitism is merely the pretext for a “smear campaign” against Corbyn and the left in general.
Britain’s Jewish community is small, about 284,000 people, or about 0.5 percent of the population, and heavily concentrated in a few areas of North London. That means many incidents that are widely noted by British Jews—such as Corbyn’s over-pronunciation of Jeffrey Epstein’s name as “Ep-schtein” in a televised debate—go unnoticed by the wider population.
A Survation poll found that 39 percent of Britons overall believe Corbyn is anti-Semitic. While that is still a remarkably high number, it is far short of the consensus that has formed among Jews.  The gulf has exacerbated the sense that their concerns are not being treated seriously by the rest of the population. As Britain’s chief rabbi, Ephraim Mirvis, wrote in The Times: “Just a few weeks before we go to the polls, the overwhelming majority of British Jews are gripped by anxiety. The question I am now most frequently asked is: What will become of Jews and Judaism in Britain if the Labour Party forms the next government?”

British orthodox Rabbi Lionel Rosenfeld of The Western/Marble Arch Synagogue, returned for the AIPAC Policy Conference in D.C. this spring with a dire warning to North Americans regarding the Socialist/Islamist influence in the Labour and Democratic Parties in the UK and the US.    

Question: We have had a year of the Labour Party getting closer to office and - what's the condition of Zionism and Zionists in the political zeitgeist in Britain today, in the UK today?  

Answer: Well I don't know if you heard the Labour MP Joan Ryan on Sunday evening Labour Friends of Israel. She's not even Jewish  - she was almost crying because what's happened to the Labour Party is really is what's happened to Zionism in the country. It's just tragic. We're on a downhill slope from last year when I spoke to you.  We have a Conservative government that is sleepwalking towards Brexit with no real discernible leadership. Everyone agrees on that and we, on the other hand, we have a Labour possible government who haven't really increased in the polls. 

Normally with them they would be miles ahead - but they're not because of this man, Corbyn. Because of his refusal to eject antisemites from his party, and because of the general fear of so many Jews in Britain that anti--semitism is taking a real hold on what was a great supporter of the State of Israel, the Labour Party.   

Question: Hasn't the Jewish community in the UK traditionally been a liberal-minded politically?  

Answer:  Very much so. Very much like the Jews of United States of America, great Democratic supporters - so have - I mean I happen to know that many of great rabbis have been quietly Labour supporters but not anymore. How can they be? Labour does not have any of the values that we espouse.  

Question: Particularly with regard to the Middle East and the growth of the spread of anti-semitism in Europe? Answer: Particularly with that. And also because they condemn the United States and Israel as two colonialist powers and that's how they see the world. It's becoming a left Marxist party that no one wants to touch with a bargepole, as you would say.

Question: And when you say Marxism, do you mean the beginnings of Socialism leading to Communism?

Answer: The people who are now running the Labour Party want to eject all previous Labour members of parliament
who had an idea that Tony Blair was the correct leader the new Labour are you as it used to be which was so successful and popular. They want them all out! They want to start again! 


Question: What was the psychological adjustment that it took for Liberal British Jews to say that this this party which I've voted reflexively for so long to be able to say "I'm going to vote against them now"

Answer: Because of the way they treated first of all the Jewish MPs who are in the Labour Party. And and of all the tweets and the terrible anti-semitic slurs against them. And they realized now that we are in a very toxic atmosphere politically and they don't know what to do!

No one really wants to leave and go on aliyah that's they have no intention of leaving Britain - this idea that Jews are going to be leaving Britain. I don't think it's going to happen. We just have to fight to make sure that the Conservative Party comes to its senses and can win this general election.


Question: Is the Jewish population of Britain - are they supporting the Conservatives now against Labour?

Answer: I would think there's very few Jews that I know that would vote Labour in the next general election. How can they when they are controlled by a small clique of left-wing, previous Marxists and Communists?

Mensch Foundation honors "Smokey Joe's Cafe" composer, Mike Stoller, and wife musician/ singer/ producer, Corky Hale

Mike Stoller and Jerry Lieber perform some of their hits on Late Night with David Letterman with Paul Schaffer's Band.
Mensch Foundation's Steven Geiger, songwriter Mike Stoller, pianist Corky
Hale, Richard Stellar, and Rabbi David Baron (Photo: Steve Moyer)


The Mensch Foundation's executive director, Steven Geiger, presented a ceremony at the Saban Theater / Temple of the Arts service (hosted by Rabbi David Baron) to honor the philanthropic efforts of musical couple, Mike Stoller and Corky Hale. Mike is the surviving member of rock/ rhythm 'n' blues songwriting duo, Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller ("Kansas City," "Jailhouse Rock," and "Smokey Joe's Cafe" also the title of the long-running broadway musical revue which features their music). Corky Hale is an accomplished musician, singer, and entertainment producer. 

The creative couple have become benefactors of a number of Jewish causes and liberal causes.  A recipient of their largesse, Richard Stellar of the Man/Kind Project read at the ceremony this tribute he penned:

"I’m holding a copy of Corky Hale’s biography “Uncorked!” – and if you’re looking for some really hot sex, celebrity gossip and dirt – well, uh… you’ve got the wrong book.

Eden and Illysia sing Mike's "Stand by Me" to the Stollers 
(Photo: Steve Moyer)
As a matter of fact I really don’t need to read about Corky, and Mike, her husband of almost fifty years.  I mean, not only have I seen them in Temple since I first found Temple of the Arts, but I’ve been fortunate enough to be on the receiving end of their charity and friendship.

It was only a few years ago when Sharon Farber and I approached Corky and Mike to support the performance of Sharon’s Bestemming Concerto.  This was a work that featured the voice of a holocaust survivor and hero, another congregant, Curt Lowens. Corky and Mike’s support enabled the voices of Holocaust survivors to ring out.  They also supported, and still support our efforts through Man/Kind to feed impoverished Holocaust survivors.  And if you think all they do is write checks, you’d be wrong.

Corky and Mike had me over to to their house for lunch to discuss the recent wave of anti-Semitism that is infecting high schools.  We brainstormed, and came up with a program called The Empathy Express, that brings high school students who appear in anti-Semitic YouTube videos to Holocaust museums, led by celebrities and survivors.  Some of you may remember  Scared Straight, the old television series that brought at-risk delinquent teenagers to prisons, where they learned first hand where hate for your fellow man can lead.

At the risk of sounding selfish, it’s not only me and Sharon and our efforts to fight anti-Semitism who they have helped.

Mike, who wrote the anthems of our youth – the songs we hummed in school, the songs we sang when our children were born, when we made out, when we broke up – Mike’s affinity for the human condition made it natural for him to reach out – and reach out he did.  Mike joined forces with HomeBoy Industries here in Los Angeles to provide rehabilitation through music.  HomeBoy’s “Music Heals” program has helped those who are looking for a break to ‘take a sad song and make it better’.  It is the inspiration of the arts that builds bridges. And building bridges is what Mike and Corky do best.




Together, Mike and Corky breathed life into the Southern Poverty Law Center where the Civil Rights Memorial Theater bares their name.  Having read about an unusual number of teenage pregnancies in Compton was the impetus for Mike and Corky to fund Planned Parenthoods Dorothy Hecht Clinic – named in honor of Corky’s mom.

As a student at the University of Wisconsin, Corky became the first white person to join the NAACP.  As a member of Temple of the Arts – well look around, Corky and Mike have been huge benefactors.

If a bay needed healing, Corky and Mike were there with Heal The Bay, if a fence needed mending, Corky and Mike were there with Habitat for Humanity, and if the elderly needed a commitment from the community, Corky and Mike supported The Jewish Homes for the Aging.

Healing the cleft palates of children through Smile Train, feeding those who are hungry through Jewish Family Services, and addressing the cancer of gun ownership that is killing our children, Corky and Mike work diligently to Stop Gun Violence.

If there is a cause that needs a champion, then two super heroes are better than one.  My non-profit would not exist if it weren’t for their help.  Our concerto would not have been played if it weren’t for their help.  Women’s reproduction rights would not be as tenuous and at risk if it weren’t for their help.

Thank you Mike. Thank you Corky.  I know that you’d probably want to be anywhere else than to have your resume of giving made public, but – you deserve this award, and I am honored to be here to tell everyone what I already know."


Transcript from video:

Steven Geiger: Both Corky and Mike have done a great deal for the Jewish community for Holocaust survivors, it's a whole list of things that certifies them as being Mensches and there's very few Mensches around. And I'm very happy that I had this opportunity to award them.


Hale: We don't only do it for Jews or the Holocaust.

Geiger: That's the most important one.

Hale: Well no I think everything we do is very important because, for example in Montgomery, Alabama they've named the civil rights memorial theater for us because we work for a lot of different groups. We work for the NAACP and we work for the Democrats and we were . . . 


He was raised in New York yes but I was raised in a town of 11,000 where there were five Jewish families and so my father wanted us to the only synagogue was 30 miles away so we were - my brother and I were driven there every Sunday so that my father said so we would know we were Jewish - and I was shocked tonight my brother was singing.

JewTube: Why would they drive you there on Sunday? 

Hale: Because that's when we had services - a Sunday school our Sunday school.  I'm a farm girl. I call myself a Jewish farm girl because it is in the sticks they're really they were I guess eleven twelve thousand people and there were five Jewish families. So the temple we we are a benefactor of this temple - yes I am - and we support the Jewish Homes for the Aged. And I still - the Dorot in New York which is in New York which is also a Jewish people from Holocaust but I mean we support a lot of everything! And that's why this wonderful man honored us tonight, which I'm very pleased by that! 



1996 First National Tour of "Smokey Joe's Cafe - the music of Lieber and Stoller"

With help from David Zucker, comic "Mossad" movie humanizes Israel's intelligence agency in the spirit of "The Naked Gun"

Israel Film Festival impressario, Meir Fenigstein announced his plans for the 2019 Israel Film Festival in Hollywood before the summer.


Little did he know of the popularity that would be achieved by Israel's controversial comedy "Mossad" during the summer. 
Aaron-Man character in a scene from Israeli comedy "Mossad"
In it, a Mossad agent and a CIA agent battle each other over who'll save the world from a terrorist organization. Watch trailer:

Filmmaker, Alon Gur Arye's popular Israeli movie comedy has a double-edge - while a madcap production for Israeli audiences, what effect will international showings of  his "Mossad" movie have on public perceptions of Israel and the deterrent effect of the Mossad's secret-service image?


"The Naked Gun" and "Airplane" franchise creator, David Zucker story-consulted with Mr. Arye pre-production in Israel. JooTube asked him about his role, his perceptions, and his view of this Mossad/CIA spoof's effect on Israel's image & security. Director, Alon Gur Arye, joins in the conversation.


Filmmaker, David Zucker (creator of "The Naked Gun" comedy movie series) appears with Alon Gur Arye, about the spoof-movie, "Mossad" following it's premiere at Israel Film Festival in Los Angeles on November 16th. Panel interviewer: Israeli-American journalist David ("Dudi") Caspi.

Steven Geiger brought a cake for David Zucker & Alon Gur Arye

To learn about availability of the move on digital distribution, as well as full English dubs, spin-offs, and possible sequels, follow the Mossad movie at its website http://mosad.co.il (intentional misspelling).

Israeli comedy, "Forgiveness," shows there CAN be honor, even redemption, among thieves

From: "Cut ‘Forgiveness’ some slack" by Hannah Brown in the Jerusalem Post October 15, 2019

"Forgiveness," the latest movie by Guy Amir and Hanan Savyon, the creators of "Maktub," one of the most commercially successful movies in Israeli history, is a light-hearted, silly caper/comedy with dramatic and sentimental undertones.

Stars of Israeli "Forgiveness" "Mechilah" Guy Amir, Hanan Savyon, producer Adar Shafran at Israel Film Fest



In short, it’s the kind of movie critics tend to hate and audiences tend to love. As the late New Yorker film critic Pauline Kael once said, a lot of movie reviewers act as if they wish they could see The Seventh Seal (a heavy film about death and redemption by Ingmar Bergman) every day. Forgiveness doesn’t aspire to be anything more than a very Israeli story of two shlubby guys who ruin each other’s lives, drive each other crazy and forgive each other – and get into a lot of trouble along the way.

Strung together like a series of comedy set pieces, it’s the latest local movie – like the summer’s big hit, Mossad – to go for popular success and lure audiences away from Hollywood films, network television and Netflix, and it mostly hits the mark. 

Addressing the audience directly, Israeli cast of "Forgiveness" Guy Amir, Hanan Savyon, Alon Aboutboul, with producer Alon Shafran & Festival director Meir Fenigstein




Aimed at the Israelis most filmmakers forget, it’s set in a town right on the Gaza border, and missiles and red alerts are woven into the plot. It opens as Shaul (Guy Amir) and Nissan (Hanan Savyon) two lifelong friends, have decided to rob a postal bank. They think they’ve got a great a plan, but just from looking at them, you can tell it’s not going to work out. Shaul is going to enter the bank via the sewer and crack the safe. All Nissan has to do is be the lookout. What could possibly go wrong? Since Nissan is wearing open-toed slippers – the first of many only-in-Israel touches – he bangs his foot and screams, alerting those sleeping in a nearby apartment. He flees and goes abroad, leaving Shaul to crawl up into police custody. 

Writer/actors Guy Amir and Hanan Savyon with producer Alon Shafran at Israel Film Festival in Los Angeles

Three years later, Shaul gets out of prison and no one is there to greet him but Nissan. Only it’s not the Nissan he once knew. His old friend has become religious and now has a long beard and a black hat and coat, in addition to a van covered with ultra-Orthodox inspirational stickers. Shaul doesn’t want to see him – all he wants is his share of the money, which Nissan has hidden. As they argue, a siren sounds, the first of many scenes interrupted by missile fire. Shaul heads home, to his wife (Noa Koler of Our Boys and The Wedding Plan), who is still angry at him for the robbery and his daughter, who is embarrassed by him. His wife is working double shifts as a manicurist, trying to make money to send their daughter to London to study ballet.
Mechila / Forgiveness poster

The money Nissan hid has disappeared, of course, and the two soon team up again to steal from a Bedouin sheik and from the local gangster (Alon Aboutboul), who stores his ill-gotten cash in his stable and whose wife complains that the cash he hands her for shopping sprees smells like horse manure. Tsahi Halevi (Mossad) plays the gangster’s right-hand man. Shaul and Nissan don various disguises – Nissan dresses like a Bedouin at one point – and get into increasingly improbable predicaments. But the plot really doesn’t matter: It’s obvious from the first second that Shaul will get the money, that his wife will forgive him, Nissan will end up with the lovely singing widow (Shiri Maimon, in her acting debut) and that Shaul will forgive Nissan for leaving him behind.
Alon Aboutboul, on his role as mafia drug kingpin in Mechilah ("Forgiveness")

 

The most entertaining part of this film is watching the two comic actors spar, and how much you enjoy the film will depend on how much they charm you. The duo, who created and starred in the hit television series Asfur, and who co-directed this film, have great rapport and always seem to be having a good time, no matter how dire their predicament. And they throw in a few unexpected touches, like an Arabic version of the classic song, “La Bamba.”


The movie is set during the Days of Awe. Highbrows who can’t forgive audiences for flocking to a movie like this should remember that the profits from Forgiveness will finance dozens of art movies.

Do Jewish & Israeli media professionals have a responsibility to not incite anti-Israelism through media?

Should Israel offer Oscars and international festivals movies  which blame Jewish Zionists for the failure of peace from Gaza and Judea/Samaria Muslims?
Israel Film Fest in L.A. debuted with "Incitement" movie guilting Israel's zionist-right for scuttling peace by sacrificing
Judea and Samaria for Palestinian state through Yigal Amir (Yehuda Nahari Halevi) assassinating of Yitzhak Rabin
The image of Israel and Israelis internationally has been beleaguered by enemies' media and political campaigns for years. Inherently liberal News Directors and Editors at global and regional news agencies, influenced by Muslim immigration advocates, have adopted an pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel editorial position - and expect that bias from field reporters - even those in Israel. Decades of anti-Israel press reportage have contributed to negative attitudes towards Israel, Israelis, and the public image of Jews in general.

The latest Anti-Defamation League survey reveals heightened levels of anti-Semitic attitudes in Europe and the Middle East. In Germany and Austria, nearly one in three respondents agree that the behavior of Jews is what causes antisemitism. 60% of European Muslim people surveyed did not agree that Israel has the right to exist as a homeland for the Jewish people.

A University of Maryland Critical Issues Poll, fielded by Nielson Scarborough, conducted in September and October 2018 reported that a large number of surveyed Americans support imposing sanctions (or more serious measures) if Israeli settlements in the West Bank continue to expand: 40 percent of Americans support such measures, including a majority of Democrats (56 percent) among a nationally representative sample of 2,352 Americans. Foreign Policy Magazine , in December 2018.

During the past decade, for an international film festival to accept an Israeli-produced film, it would have to be a liberal, critical of Israel (rather than zionistic or Jewish State advocating) production. This is similarly the case even by program selectors at Jewish Film Festivals internationally and even film festivals portraying themselves as Israeli film festivals (such as in Los Angeles, New York, Chicago, or Philadelphia). 

With Jewish people assaulted and killed in the streets of their own countries and bigotry towards Israelis and Israeli interests (physical and political) persisting, do Jews - and Israelis in particular - bear a responsibility in defending Jews and the Jewish State against lies and defamation? Do primarily liberal TV and filmmakers who commonly produce programs for domestic, Israeli citizens' eyes (which emphasize criticism, conflict, controversy, and turmoil) - have a patriotic responsibility to no "air our dirty laundry" to under-informed, often anti-Israel predisposed audiences outside of Israel?

Interview with Hillel Newman, Israeli Consul General to Southwest US:

Question: We're here at the Israel Film Festival do the filmmakers who come here do they or the the programmers who program the films that are shown here - do they have a responsibility to show, to depict Israel in a favorable light?


Hillel Newman, Israeli Consul Gen to Southwest US

Answer: Israel is a country what we call a strong democracy. . .  There are red lines. Red lines are like movies or people who support BDS - divestment or boycott of Israel - or people who refuse to recognize the existence of the State of Israel. Those are the red lines that we wish not to cross and the movie that will support BDS or do something which crosses a red line will support terrorism or anti-semitism, we will not be there.

Question: But the film that's being shown tonight, Incitement it's incriminating to the right - they're blaming the Zionist-right in this picture and while it may be popular for commercial purposes, do the programmers have a responsibility to show things which are less incriminating on either side or blaming for tragedies such as the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin?

Answer: Well, first of all my being here is not an endorsement of one movie or another. I'm just being here for the the festival itself and they're gonna display many movies during the festival. I'm in support of the festival, in general. 

Regarding this the Incitement movie (this is not the inciting movie) it's an era there are different opinions about it. I read up the reviews. I'm not a movie critique or reviewer. I'm aware of the different opinions about the movie. I understand where the moving is coming from. That it's just trying to portray an angle of of where the assassin of Rabin comes from. One doesn't have to accept the movie, one doesn't have to agree with the movie. It's controversial - one can disagree with the movie - that's legitimate."


Sharon Harel Cohen received Achievement in Film Award
from Meir Fenigstein's Israel Film Festival in L.A.
The Israel Film Festival in Beverly Hills, presented its Achievement in Film to Sharon Harel-Cohen, who produced IDF entertainers' story, "Ha Lehaka ("The Troupe) in 1977 (which featured drummer Meir Fenigstein in an acting/performing role. He founded and has been directing the Israel Film Festival for 33 years). 

Mrs. Cohen discusses the conundrum of why, in the face of growing anti-Israel attitudes, a dearth exists in "explanation" (hasbara) films and TV educating about Israel's history and struggle against detractors and enemies. 
 


Q:  Since that time since the early mid '60s, Exodus and Cast a Giant Shadow, there haven't been many films made depicting Israel story. What do you think about that?

A:  I think it's time to make make more movies like that.

Q:  Do you feel that Israeli filmmakers have a responsibility to help tell Israel's story amid the sheker (lies) and defamation?

A:  It's interesting - Israeli filmmakers don't really focus on that do they? I think they dont. Israeli filmmakers focus on their society. And stories within that. And issues they deal in. They deal with Israeli issues rather than how the world would perceive Israel. I think you're right, though.

Q:  Israel is not aware of the problems internationally?

A:  Yes but they don't have the same. . . so if you're in the States andyou're in New York or Los Angeles and you're thinking about Israel it's very different than if you actually ...

Q:  Or if you're in London.

A:  Or in London, definitely.

Q:  So everyone accuses at Hollywood, there's so many Jews working in Hollywood, but it doesn't seem to have worked on behalf of the Zionist history or Israel's cause. How about in England is there a chance that that even theaters would show movies that show Israel in a favorable light?

A:  In the UK, BDS is very very strong. And I think you will find that a lot of Palestinian money and efforts are going into that. Actually our movie, Incitement, was in the London Film Festival and the people in the London Festival were worried that there would be riots outside. There wasn't any.

Q:  Are you a producer or the producer?

A:  I'm producer of the film Incitement, yeah. The film is about the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin.

Q:  At the time was he the Prime Minister?

A:  He was a prime minister and it was during the Oslo period. And he was very close to a peace treaty with the Palestinians. It was during the second stage of Oslo. But he was assassinated.

Q:  Are films - even films which are which are critical of Israel will they get shown? Will they get picked up - if not by cinemas then by cable channels or satellite channels?

A:  In the UK?

Q:  In the UK  - anywhere in Europe?

A:  I think Israeli films are picked up, but not in many numbers. In the UK. In Europe I think that France shows many Israeli films. I think it depends. The UK doesn't."


Video of Sharon Harel Cohen's award acceptance speech below at the Israel Film Festival courtesy filmfestivals.com